So…what’s a system?

So…this is a slightly different post than my normal…. but it might (?) be of interest (perhaps helpful) to others.

It comes from me ‘grappling’ with a fair bit of thinking. I was trying to write about something that keeps bugging me…and, to do so, I had to do a lot of groundwork on definitions.

This post sets out where I got to on this definitional journey…so that I can use it in a subsequent post* on [the following terrible working title] ‘Complexity, organisation, purpose, power and constraints’.

* which, by writing those words, might make me finish it.

Here goes:

A system:

Simple definition: “a network of inter-dependent components that work together to try to accomplish the aim [purpose] of the system” (W. Edwards Deming)

Complex definition: “any network of interactions that has dynamic coherence” (Cynefin wiki)

Notes:

  • systems are conceptual constructs (observer-dependent) through which we make sense of, and intervene in, reality. As such, any so-called system is a way of viewing, understanding and/or acting upon a situation for a particular purpose.
  • the simple definition assumes that a purpose can be identified. The complex definition does not require the existence of a purpose.
  • The ‘dynamic coherence’ wording within the complex definition refers to the persistence of recognisable patterns of interactions over time, despite continual changes in actors, relationships and environmental conditions.

(System) Boundary: a conceptual device used to distinguish what is considered part of a (so called) system from what is not, for the purpose of understanding and intervening.

System boundaries do not exist objectively in nature in the form in which they are drawn for inquiry. Rather, they are analytical distinctions made by observers. Different observers may legitimately draw different boundaries around the same situation.

Notes:

  • Whilst the conceptual boundary distinguishes a system from its wider environment (i.e. an inside and outside), it does not make it independent of that environment. The ‘outside’ influences, and is influenced by, the ‘inside’.

Using these base definitions, then each definition below should be understood as useful lenses for sense-making rather than as a fixed taxonomy.

An eco(logical) system: A community of interacting actors and their environment that co-evolve over time, with their relationships continuously influencing and adapting to one another.

A social (or socio-economic) system: A system comprised of people, and the relationships, norms and structures through which they interact.

Notes:

  • a social system can be viewed as one form of coherent human interactions within, and interacting with, a wider ecosystem
  • social systems contain socially constructed realities (things that exist only because we collectively behave as though they do) such as money, laws & regulations, and institutions.

Together, eco(logical) and social systems are referred to as socio-ecological systems, which encompass all the physical, biological and socially constructed realties of a community and its environment.

Notes:

  • This broader definition emphasises humans as part of (and not separate to) nature.

A human-designed system: A system intentionally created, structured or modified by people to enable co-ordinated activity towards a sufficiently shared purpose.

Notes:

  • different actors may understand the purpose differently
  • outcomes will emerge through ongoing interactions between actors operating within, and responding to, the human-designed system. The actual behaviours and outcomes may differ from those intended by its designers
  • a human-designed system sits within, interacts with, and is constrained by the wider ecosystem.

 A necessary concept for considering against human-designed systems is:

Power: The ability of an actor to shape possibilities (e.g. through shaping purpose, constraints and boundaries).

Notes:  

  • This definition recognises that different actors (e.g. people) have differing capacities to shape possibilities
  • The word is ‘shape’ rather than ‘determine’. Power may influence what is possible or likely, but it does not guarantee outcomes.

A service system: A type of human-designed system whose primary purpose is to help people (e.g. customers2) meet needs, solve problems, or achieve desired outcomes.

A manufacturing system: A type of human-designed system whose primary purpose is to transform materials, components, energy or other physical resources into tangible products.

Notes:

  • Unlike service systems, where the customer is the primary subject of the work, a manufacturing system primarily acts upon physical resources to create products.
  • Manufacturing systems are usually desired by (or viewable as a sub-system within) one or more service systems (e.g. cars are produced for/ purchased by customers whose service need is transportation)

Customer: a person, served by, or actively engaging with, a service system.

Notes:

  • This definition of a customer implies that they sit ‘outside’ of the service system boundary. This formulation aids in thinking about the performance of the system from their perspective (‘outside in’). In practice, outcomes emerge through the interaction of customer and service system.
  • In relational service systems3, the client is often the primary determinant of the outcome achieved, with the service system influencing, supporting and enabling change, rather than producing it directly. The role of such a service system is therefore to create the conditions in which the client can develop, decide and act. 

And so, with all the above ‘set out’ in a way that (currently) makes sense to me, I turn to:

Complex Adaptive Systems (CAS): “systems that have a large number of elements…usually called agents, that learn or adapt in response to interactions with other agents.” (John H. Holland)

Taking this slightly further:

  • Axelrod & Cohen4 set out CAS concepts in relation to agents, strategies, populations, interactions and adaption; and
  • Paul Cilliers5 set out characteristics of complex adaptive systems, which include concepts such as emergence, self-organisation, non-linearity and path-dependency .

…and that’s what I’ve been thinking about…which is the ‘hook’ (?) to my next post.

Footnotes:

1. This is similar to Peter Checkland’s concept of a (purposeful) human activity system

2. Whilst I’ve deliberately used the more generic ‘customer’ here, I often write with reference to ‘clients’. My definition of a client is ‘a customer who is the subject of a professional relationship involving assessment, judgement, advice, support, representation, care or intervention.’ i.e. client is a particular type (subset) of customer.

3. See this previous post (Part 1: Autonomy – Autonomy Support – Autonomy Enabling | Squire to the Giants) if you want to delve into potential categorisation of different archetypes of service systems.

4. Axelrod & Cohen wrote a book called ‘Harnessing Complexity: Organisational Implications of a Scientific Fronter’ in 1999

5. Paul Cilliers wrote a book called ‘Complexity and Postmodernism: Understanding Complex Systems’ in 1998.

Leave a Reply